Pagonis Menu

Happy-Tizers & Sides

Appetizers

Ease the wait for your pizza with terrific hot appetizers.
  • Chicken Tender Basket 8.99

    Chicken tenders with a side of potato wedges. Add ranch dressing for .69

  • Fried Mozzarella Sticks 6.99

    With Mama Pagoni's marinara.

  • Cheesy Garlic Bread 5.99

    Piping hot & bubbly. Served with marinara.

  • Fresh Breadsticks 3.99

    Garlic kissed. Served with marinara for dipping.

  • Garlic Kissed Bread 4.99

    Made fresh to order. Served with marinara.

  • Cheese Pizza Bread 6.49

    Garlic bread, topped with mozzarella cheese.

  • Cheese Pizza Bread with Sausage 6.99

    Garlic bread, topped with mozzarella cheese & sausage.

  • Cheese Pizza Bread with Pepperoni 6.99

    Garlic bread, topped with mozzarella cheese & pepperoni.

  • Cheese Pizza Bread with Pepperoni 6.99

    Garlic bread, topped with mozzarella cheese & pepperoni.

  • Onion Rings 5.99

    Served with zesty sauce.

  • Potato Wedges 4.99
  • Traditional Chicken Wings 12.49

    A pound of our plump, juicy chicken wings either hot or BBQ.

  • Boneless Wings 11.99

    All white meat.

  • Cheese Stuffed Breadsticks 5.99

    Garlic kissed, stuffed with cheese & served with Mama Pagoni's marinara.

  • Mama's Dipping Stick Pizza 12.99

    A dozen dipping sticks made with a garlic butter crust, topped with mozzarella & cheddar cheese, served with Mama Pagoni's pizza dipping sauce.

  • Jalapeno & Cheddar Sticks 6.99

    Stuffed Breadsticks with ranch dipping sauce.

  • Mama Pagoni's Sampler 11.99

    Fried mozzarella sticks, chicken tenders & onion rings served with ranch & marinara sauce.

  • Bruschetta 9.49

    Perfectly seasoned ripe plum tomatoes with fresh garlic, extra virgin olive oil, fresh chopped basil leaves & drizzled with balsamic vinegar. Served on toasted sliced French bread.

  • Side of Ranch Sauce 0.79
  • Side of Marinara Sauce 0.79
  • Side of Garlic Butter Sauce 0.79

Fresh Salads

Salads

All dressings are served on the side.
Extra Dressing 0.79 each

  • Chicken Bacon Salad 10.99

    Crispy or grilled chicken tossed with cheddar cheese, bacon & tomatoes nestled on a crisp bed of lettuce.

  • Garden Salad 9.99

    Broccoli, mushroom, tomatoes, green peppers, red onions & fresh parmesan.

  • Garden Salad with Chicken 11.99

    Broccoli, mushroom, tomatoes, green peppers, red onions & fresh parmesan.

  • Antipasto Salad 11.99

    Salami, pepperoni, provolone, olives & peppers in our house dressing.

  • Chef's Salad 10.99

    Lettuce, tomatoes, green peppers, black olives, salami, ham, turkey & mozzarella.

  • Wisconsin Caesar Salad 9.99

    Romaine lettuce, croutons & fresh parmesan tossed with Caesar dressing.

  • Wisconsin Caesar Salad with Chicken 11.99

    Romaine lettuce, croutons & fresh parmesan tossed with Caesar dressing.

Pizza

Thin Crust Pizza
Mozzarella Cheese

Each Pizza comes with sauce and cheese. You can add any of our delicious toppings.
See Toppings
  • Individual 9'' 9.99

    Serves 1
    Additional Toppings 0.99 each
    Double Crust (hand tossed) 1.00

  • Small 12'' 11.99

    Serves 2
    Additional Topping 1.39 each
    Double Crust (hand tossed) 1.39

  • Medium 14'' 14.99

    Serves 2-3
    Additional Topping1.59 each
    Double Crust (hand tossed) 1.59

  • Large 16'' 16.99

    Serves 3-4
    Additional Topping 1.99 each
    Double Crust (hand tossed) 2.00

  • Family 18'' 19.99

    Serves 4-5
    Additional Topping 2.49 each
    Double Crust (hand tossed) 2.50

  • Grande 22.99

    Serves 5-6
    Additional Topping 3.00 each
    Double Crust (hand tossed) 3.00

Sicilian Style Pizza Rectangular, Pan Baked

Sicilian Style Pizza comes with sauce and cheese. You can add any of our delicious toppings.
See Toppings
  • 1/4 Sheet 9''x12'' 14.99

    Mozzarella Cheese
    Additional Topping 1.25 each

  • 1/2 Sheet 12''x18'' 20.99

    Mozzarella Cheese
    Additional Topping 2.50 each

Stuffed Pizza

Stuffed Pizza comes with sauce and cheese. You can add any of our delicious toppings.
See Toppings
  • Small 12'' 15.99

    Mozzarella Cheese
    Additional Topping 1.49 each

  • Medium 14'' 18.99

    Mozzarella Cheese
    Additional Topping 1.99 each

  • Large 16'' 21.99

    Mozzarella Cheese
    Additional Topping 2.99 each

Deep Dish Pizza

Deep Dish Pizza comes with sauce and cheese. You can add any of our delicious toppings.
See Toppings
  • Individual 6'' 9.99

    Serves 1
    Additional Topping 0.99 each
    Chicago Style 1.29

  • Small 10'' 15.99

    Serves 2-3
    Additional Topping 1.49 each
    Chicago Style 1.99

  • Large 12'' 19.99

    Serves 3-4
    Additional Topping 1.99 each
    Chicago Style 2.99

Calzones

Our hand-rolled, oven-baked calzones are made from scratch with lots of mozzarella, ricotta cheese, red sauce, your favorite toppings & lots of love. Served with a side of Mama Pagoni’s favorite marinara.

See Toppings
  • Create Your Own Plain Cheese Calzone 10.99

    Small 9.99 • Large 14.99
    Additional Toppings Sm .99 • Lg 1.49

  • The House Calzone 13.49

    Pepperoni, sausage, onion & green pepper.

  • Mama Pagoni's Special Calzone 13.99

    Steak, onion, green pepper & mushroom.

  • Quattro Formaggio Calzone 13.49

    Mozzarella, cheddar, provolone & parmesan cheese.

  • Spinach Calzone 11.98

    With ricotta and mozzarella cheese.

  • Sausage Calzone 11.98

    Sausage and cheese over delicious pizza sauce.

  • Pepperoni Calzone 11.98

    Pepperoni and cheese over delicious pizza sauce.

Stromboli

Rolled pizza dough stuffed with mozzarella cheese & served with a side of Mama Pagoni’s favorite marinara.
See Toppings
  • Create Your Own Stromboli 10.99

    Plain Cheese Stromboli
    Additional Toppings 0.99

  • The Traditional Stromboli 12.49

    Pepperoni, sausage, onion & green pepper.

  • Garden Stromboli 11.99

    Spinach, mushrooms, diced tomato, green peppers & broccoli.

  • Syracuse Stuffer Stromboli 12.99

    Steak, onion, green peppers & mushroom.

  • Spinach Stromboli 11.98

    With ricotta and mozzarella cheese.

  • Sausage Stromboli 11.98

    Sausage, mushrooms and cheese over delicious red sauce.

  • Pepperoni Stromboli 11.98

    With pasta sauce and mozzarella cheese.

Pizza Toppings

Sausage • Broccoli • Extra Cheese • Extra Sauce • Ham • Pepperoni Spinach • Mushrooms • Sliced and Diced Tomatoes • Black Olives • Mild Giardiniera • Salami Ground Beef • Canadian Bacon • Green Peppers • Green Olives • Hot Giardiniera Bacon Crumbles • Meatballs • Onions • Pineapple • Jalapeño Peppers Bleu Cheese • Italian Beef • Fresh Basil • Fresh Garlic • Shrimp (available at an additional charge)

Specialty Pizza

Premium Pagoni's Pizza Creations

Thin Crust Round

  • Small 12'' 16.99

    Serves 2

  • Medium 14'' 19.99

    Serves 2-3

  • Large 16'' 23.99

    Serves 3-4

  • Family 18'' 27.99

    Serves 4-5

Sicilian

  • 1/4 Sheet 19.99

    Serves 2-3

  • 1/2 Sheet 26.99

    Serves 4-5

Deep Dish

  • Small 10'' 19.99

    Serves 2-3

  • Large 12'' 24.99

    Serves 3-4

  • The Star Special Pizza

    Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green pepper, black olive, diced tomato & mozzarella cheese.

  • The "Don" Pizza

    Italian beef, Italian sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions & mozzarella.

  • Mama Pagoni's Kitchen Sink Pizza

    Sausage, pepperoni, green peppers, onions, mushrooms & mozzarella.

  • The Ulti-Meat Pizza

    Sausage, pepperoni, ham, ground beef, bacon & mozzarella cheese.

  • The Great White Pizza

    Grilled chicken, olive oil, fresh garlic, fresh basil, spinach, red onions, diced tomatoes, romano & mozzarella cheese (no red sauce).

  • Shrimp Scampi Pizza

    Garlic buttered crust, pizza sauce, marinated shrimp & fresh garlic topped with mozzarella!

  • NEW! Margherita Pizza

    Fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, sliced tomato, extra virgin olive oil & fresh garlic sprinkled with oregano.

Pagoni's Famous Pizza Creations

Thin Crust Round

  • Small 12'' 15.99

    Serves 2

  • Medium 14'' 18.99

    Serves 2-3

  • Large 16'' 22.99

    Serves 3-4

  • Family 18'' 26.99

    Serves 4-5

Sicilian

  • 1/4 Sheet 18.99

    Serves 2-3

  • 1/2 Sheet 25.99

    Serves 4-5

Deep Dish

  • Small 10'' 18.99

    Serves 2-3

  • Large 12'' 23.99

    Serves 3-4

  • Angela's Pesto Pizza

    Basil & garlic pesto with grilled chicken on a double crust topped with pine nuts, chopped tomato & mozzarella.

  • Barbecue Chicken Pizza

    Grilled chicken marinated in tangy BBQ sauce with cilantro, sliced red onions & mozzarella.

  • Hawaiian Pizza

    Canadian bacon, ham, pineapple & mozzarella.

  • B.L.T. Pizza

    Bacon, ham & mozzarella cheese. Baked then topped with lettuce, tomatoes & mayo or try ranch dressing for a different twist!

  • Chicken Ranch Pizza

    Grilled chicken, ranch dressing, garlic, onions, tomatoes, mozzarella & cheddar baked on a double crust.

  • Quattro Formaggio Pizza

    Mozzarella, cheddar, provolone & parmesan cheese.

  • Jerk Chicken Pizza

    Marinated jerk chicken with red onions, jalapeños, pineapple, cilantro, pineapple & fresh garlic.

  • Veggie Garden Special Pizza

    Spinach, green peppers, fresh mushrooms, sliced tomatoes, broccoli & mozzarella.

  • Chicken Alfredo Pizza

    Grilled chicken, Alfredo sauce, garlic & broccoli with mozzarella cheese baked on a double crust.

  • All American Cheeseburger Pizza

    Ground beef, bacon, cheddar, tomatoes & Italian sausage.

  • The Mac Pizza

    Macaroni & cheese pizza prepared with aged cheeses.

  • Buffalo Chicken Ranch Pizza

    Grilled chicken, buffalo ranch dressing, garlic, red onions, tomatoes, mozzarella & cheddar cheese. Baked on double crust.

Fresh Pasta Entrées

Pasta

Each pasta entrée includes your choice of french bread or fresh breadsticks.
  • Baked Mostaccioli 11.99

    Marinara sauce, topped with mozzarella cheese & baked to perfection.
    Add 2 Meatballs or Meat Sauce for 2.49 each

  • Fettuccine Alfredo 13.99

    Mama Pagoni’s creamy alfredo sauce with fresh parmesan cheese.
    Add Broccoli 2.00

  • Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken 14.99

    Mama Pagoni’s creamy alfredo sauce with fresh parmesan cheese.
    Add Broccoli 2.00

  • Fettuccine Alfredo with Shrimp 17.99

    Mama Pagoni’s creamy alfredo sauce with fresh parmesan cheese.
    Add Broccoli 2.00

  • Meat Ravioli 10.99

    6 Ravioli stuffed with meat.
    Double, 10 for 16.99

  • Cheese Ravioli 10.99

    6 Ravioli stuffed with cheese.
    Double, 10 for 16.99

  • Pasta Mona Lisa with Sausage 15.99

    Sauteed mushrooms, onions, green peppers & roasted red peppers in garlic butter sauce on a bed of penne pasta.

  • Pasta Mona Lisa with Shrimp 18.99

    Sauteed mushrooms, onions, green peppers & roasted red peppers in garlic butter sauce on a bed of penne pasta.

  • Pasta Mona Lisa with Chicken 15.99

    Sauteed mushrooms, onions, green peppers & roasted red peppers in garlic butter sauce on a bed of penne pasta.

  • Chicken Parmigiana 13.99

    Whole lightly breaded chicken breast topped with marinara sauce on spaghetti & smothered with cheese.

  • Chicken Pesto Cavatappi 14.99

    With your choice of basil or sun-dried tomato cream pesto with grilled chicken.

  • Lasagna in Marinara Sauce 13.99

    Family favorite! Hand layered, made fresh to order with your choice of meat, cheese or spinach. Fresh to order!

  • Ulti-Meat Spaghetti 14.99

    Mama Pagoni's favorite meat sauce with meatballs on a bed of spaghetti.

  • Build Your Own Pasta 11.99

    1: Choose Your Pasta - Spaghetti, Fettuccine, Mostaccioli, or Cavatappi
    2: Choose Your Sauce: Marinara 10.99 or Meat Sauce, Alfredo, Basil Cream Pesto, or Sun-Dried Tomato Cream Pesto 13.99
    3: Add Your Choice of Meat - Grilled Chicken, Italian Sausage, or Meatballs 2.49 - Baked with lotsa Mozzarella 2.49

Gourmet Sandwiches

Sandwiches

Served with chips and a pickls.
  • Philly Steak Sandwich 10.49

    With onion, green pepper, mushroom, mozzarella & BBQ sauce on garlic bread.

  • Philly Chicken Sandwich 10.49

    With onion, green pepper, mushroom, mozzarella & BBQ sauce on garlic bread.

  • Hot Ham & Cheese Sandwich 9.49

    On garlic kissed bread.

  • Buffalo Chicken Sandwich 10.49

    Buffalo sauce, crispy chicken, romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cheddar, bleu cheese or ranch.

  • Grilled Chicken Caesar 9.99

    With romaine lettuce, bacon, parmesan & cheddar cheese tossed in Caesar dressing.

  • Chicken Parmesan Sandwich 9.49

    With crispy chicken, marinara sauce, parmesan & mozzarella on garlic bread.

  • Turkey Melt Sandwich 9.49

    With mozzarella, cheddar & sautéed onions.

Straight From Chicago

Get it dipped for free! Add marinara, hot or mild giardiniera on request, no charge.
  • Chicago Italian Beef Sandwich 10.49

    Thinly sliced beef.
    Add mozzarella for 0.79.

  • Italian Sausage Sandwich 10.49

    Comes with Italian sausage.
    Add mozzarella for 0.79.

  • Italian Beef & Sausage Sandwich 11.49

    Comes with beef & Italian sausage.
    Add mozzarella for 0.79.

  • Italian Meatball Sandwich 9.49

    With red sauce.
    Add mozzarella for 0.79.

Submarines & Wraps

Choose Italian bread or wrap.

Paninis

Served with chips & a pickle.
  • Chicken Ranch Panini 9.99

    Grilled chicken breast, bacon, sliced tomatoes, provolone cheese, topped off with ranch dressing.

  • Turkey Panini 9.99

    Thinly sliced ham or turkey, sliced tomatoes, red onions, cheddar & mozzarella cheese grilled to perfection.

  • Ham Panini 9.99

    Thinly sliced ham or turkey, sliced tomatoes, red onions, cheddar & mozzarella cheese grilled to perfection.

  • Club Panini 9.99

    Thinly sliced ham, turkey, bacon, sliced tomatoes, red onions, cheddar & provolone cheese.

  • Tuscan Chicken Panini 9.99

    Sliced chicken breast, roasted red peppers, sliced tomatoes, mozzarella cheese & zesty tomato pesto!

Desserts, Kids, & Beverages

It's The Bomb

Invented here. Pagoni’s dessert bombs are filled with creamy fillings, topped with icing or powdered sugar & served warm. Made to order!
  • Chocolate Bomb 9.99

    Chewy, sweet crust overflowing with hazelnut chocolate, topped with powdered sugar.

  • Apple Bomb 9.99

    Chewy, sweet crust stuffed with hot apple pie filling, topped with icing. It's the bomb!

  • Cherry Bomb 9.99

    Calzone-style crust filled with cherry pie filling & drizzled with icing.

Soda

Nothing like a cold soda to go with your pizza. We offer Coke, Diet Coke, and Sprite in 2 Liters and cans.
  • Cans 1.79
  • 2 Liter 3.59

Just For Kids

All Dine-In kids selections include a small fountain drink or glass of white or chocolate milk.
  • Kid's Cutie Pie Tray 8.99

    Kid's sauce & top their own pizza with up to 2 toppings.
    Dine in only.

  • Kid's 2-Topping Pizza 7.99

    Additional toppings 0.99 each.

  • Kid's Chicken Strips 7.99

    With potato wedges.

  • Kid's Spaghetti 6.99

    With marinara sauce & a breadstick.

Scroll to Top
Skip to content